Lovely post! Amazing images!

I love this. This look is rich and satisfying. I agree with you when you said that there is a difference between maximalism and clutter/hoarding. A maximalist room is curated and has an overarching concept and strives to make a particular impression, but clutter/hoarding is random collecting with no vision or goal. I am tired of sterile rooms that tell you nothing about the people who live in them. I have some keepsakes displayed and am told this is clutter. I told some relatives I was putting up wallpaper in my bedroom and oh the shocked comments I got, about how it would decrease the resale value of my home. Well, in that case, I’ll shrug and give the hissy buyer a discount. Why should I live in a stark room to please a future buyer of my home?

I believe everyone should live in the home they love, not be a slave to trends. Trends are changing constantly and to keep up is futile.
I like classic pieces and those that tell a story of a life lived. But, I could not live in any of the above homes. Too much color, too much stuff, just too much! My mind would never rest. I would feel anxious and discombobulated.

I am totally “All in” the Maximalism movement. I have tried editing so that I can keep up with the latest minimalist craze, and it makes me sad to remove my beloved treasures. Now, I’m off to go find some bold curtains for my naked windows.

Kristie, I agree with you in the theory and believe that as the last commentator mentioned, we all need to surround our selves with the things that we love and feel comfortable with, whether that is a little or a lot of “stuff”. I have lived with what I call a “retail mindset” for over 40 years and that is that things need to appear “fresh and new”. It doesn’t mean they have to be, “appear” being the operative word here. I frequently move things from room to room to give a different look to a space. My husband laughs at me because he never knows where that bauble, obelisk, or vase will turn up. it may be in the Great room today but next month it will live in the dining room for awhile. Rarely do I ever display items in the same way. A “fixed” mantle display would make me crazy after about two months. I love to emphasize seasonal changes in my decor and thus the next time around could be a year later so heaven forbid, it be the exact same as I arranged it last year! Some things are brought forward to enjoy while others take a back seat for awhile. It makes the house look fresh and keeps me from looking at the “same old, same old.

I like a lot of color, history, and meaning to the objects in my home but I am also a minimalist in the sense that I don’t like a crowded home. I prefer a few fun items on my mantle rather than an overflow. Like you, I have a place for items that I rotate out: I don’t throw away, I just let them rest for a while. That’s why I like Marie Kondo; in her book she writes that we shouldn’t only focus on the things we don’t want, but the things that bring us joy. She is not a minimalist in the sense of having a sterile, colorless home. If it brings you joy, keep it!

Although I don’t begrudge anyone for their style preferences, I wish I could live as a minimalist. After cleaning out my dad’s home after his death, I became a “less is more” gal. I strive to keep from having too many accessories, using only items that are meaningful to me. I do love art, but even that can be too much. Although I love most of the colors in these rooms, the amount of stuff would overwhelm me emotionally. I definitely don’t love buying tchotchke for the sake of decor. I am currently forcing myself to have some beautiful throw pillows, even though they aren’t necessary, they do add beauty and a bit of comfort.

I think it is perfect for some personalities, but those pictures above cause me to feel anxious. There should be freedom for people to decorate with what they love, whether minimal or max. The era of Pinterest and the internet has dictated a lot of what a person feels brave enough to do in their own home. It has squelched creativity as much as helped.

I like the Nick Olsen bedroom!

It sounds like Maximalism is just the new way to sum up “British Country Manor House”. (Which I love and live in myself!)

Kristie, I am not a minimalist, but I do get overwhelmed by multiple patterns and/or strong colors in a single space. I say no to sterility, but yes to serenity; no to clutter, but yes to complexity. Anything does not go. I’ve seen rooms in House Beautiful that are filled with totally unrelated patterns and colors. To me, that is the reverse of beauty. Symmetry and related elements have been marks of beauty for thousands of years, for good reasons. Miles Redd is very talented, and gets away with a lot, but his rooms above skate close to the edge. Some of the others you posted go over it. IMHO, of course!

Love the content and pictures! So happy to add my name to the list of maximalism lovers… Living confortable and surranded by things you Love is always on Trend!!

I love this blog post! I think i fall somewhere in between. It’s these nostalgic/historic/sentimental items that truly make a house a home and give it soul which so many interiors seem to be lacking these days!

Most of these pictures are a bit too much for me, but I am not a minimalist either. One thing I have to have around me is some color. So many bloggers homes look like a white out in a blizzard, and oh so boring. I like certain old things , but I also mix it with new things, preferably something unique and hand made, not Chinese mass produced things. I’m not going back to wallpaper again though. Been there and done that. Too hard to remove!

Those images make me think of English Country House crossbred with Dorthy Draper or one of her designer colleagues with some 60s haute chic thrown in. Some are not quite my thing, but I like color and the unexpected and mixing styles.

I have always been a more is more type of person, but and a home needs specific places for specific things to function. There is a limit on how much one can handle. and that varies from person to person. Didn’t realize this until I went over the managable limit for me in my current home and will downsize soon. The Gentle Art of Swedish Death Cleaning is another approach–not in a morbid sense, but thinking about what do you want to leave behind. At my age, that is becoming an issue.

I LOVE the part about keeping books! I had to downsize a lot of mine when moving from my 4-bedroom house to a shared apartment. What was left had to live in storage for a year, but I just brought them out and it’s so good to have them back.

I must be a “medium-ist” :). More than minimalist, but way less than almost all of the photos. My stress level went right through the roof just looking at them. I feel like my eyes don’t have anywhere to rest and that they are ping ponging around trying to figure out what to land on lol. I also think very few people (particularly non-professionals) have any idea how to curate so many diverse items, colors and patterns. So while I agree this can be a very successful look (even if I’m not a fan), I think many people who attempt it will create something notably less photo worthy. But if they love it, that’s what matters :).

You mentioned that the exception to all this should be when we are selling our homes. I would suggest that the other exception is when we are of an age where our expected life span, or ability to live independently, is getting short. I think we have an obligation to either pare down our stuff or make sure there’s money for a professional to do it after we’re gone. Anything less puts a HUGE burden on those who have to deal with it all. The people we love shouldn’t have to spend weeks and months sorting and disposing of our possessions, all the while feeling guilty and resentful. Can you tell I’ve done this a time or two :)?

Loved this blog entry – very thought provoking!

You are speaking my language! My motto is more is more.

Wow! Some of these rooms are gorgeous! They’re a bit too much to live in day to day for me personally. But there are definitely elements to the rooms I really love.
I find it kinda funny that minimalists claim nobility. The rooms often look so emaciated that I often thought they were merely a reflection of their owners inner deadness. You know because beige is so restful and peaceful and all….

Interior design has been so homogenized by HGTV cookie cutter design! People think there is only one bland, gray/beige way to decorate their homes, and unfortunately it has also carried over into prospective home buyers’ expectations.

There has always been a portion of the population who has continued to live with pattern, color, and beautiful , classic (and expensive) wall coverings regardless of what is being sold to the general public on television.

Love this post. It makes me feel okay with classic looks that may not be popular right now. I have grown to love a serene feeling ( and off white walls) in my home, but that doesn’t have to mean no color in my rooms.

Opulent comes to mind when I look at the photos in the new maximalism post. Some people prefer that others prefer minimalism (I happen to). There is no right or wrong. Your home has to reflect your own style whatever that is. Trends come and go sTyle never goes out of fashion !!!!!

A MINIMAL amount of MAXIMALISM works for me – if that makes any sense !! Lol

I think all of those images are inspiring! You know I love colors and patterns, but I think I’m more of “Edited New Maximalist”. I like bigger, bolder, more singular pieces rather than a lot of smaller things on tables and display areas. Does that make sense?

I can see why this is a favorite post of yours. First of all, the photos are so beautiful and stunning. They really showcase the art of curating a maximalism space.

For me, I personally fall somewhere in between. While a full, cluttered space (disoragnaized) makes my shoulders move right past my ears, all of your images did not do that. You can clearly see how well the spaces were curated.

We recently purchased an investment property that would fall in the maximalism category. I was drawn to the home for a number of reasons however when we did the walkthrough (twice), I kept saying to the real estate agent, “I would love to sit down with the owner and hear alll about their life.” If was clear every piece had a story – and there were a lot of pieces! I know this is one of the reasons we closed on this property – the home had such a good feeling.

Thanks for sharing this and your thoughts.

Love this post! While minimalism might be right for some, if we were all alike it would be a boring world! Love the point about curation not collecting and the reuse of things!

Kristie –
Great post and very timely for me! I enjoy reading g psychological responses from others, which is what design is all about, isn’t it? I guess I fall into a split personality camp. I love and embrace both minimal and maximal. After seasonal change-outs that take me from the holiday hubbub (displaying my old Charles Dickens books, hats, old silver sets, greens, lots of layers, etc.), I peel it back to what my kids laughingly call my Starship Enterprise look (white on white with a few select pieces, roll up the rugs). I have lit glass cabinets above my kitchen wall cabinets for vignettes that change out every 4 months. The 1/4” back panels simply change from white to haint blue to red. Point is, I love these psychological changeable “escape hatches“ for myself and clients. I love a good Transfirmer trick.

In this week’s newsletter from Austin Kleon (author “Steal Like An Artist”), he touched on the frequent maximalism environment of artists’ ever changing, wonderfully cluttered, creative minds and spaces. I call it curated chaos.

Lastly (sorry for going on), tomorrow I’m helping a designer friend hang art and stage her newly remodeled main floor. She’s done the same with me giving each other playful fresh eyes. She’s very much a maximalist and it should be fun!

Thanks again so much for your timely, inspirational piece, Kristie.

Wow such a plethora of excellent images!!! I’m fully on board for embracing color, pattern and new maximalism in the home.

I love it! Nicely done post, Kristie! I’ve found everyone has their own levels of tolerance for either maximalist or minimalist interiors. I have no problem with any style as long as it is well done! What is appalling and lazy is when sheeple don’t think through what will bring THEM joy, and just do whatever the crowd/media/HGTV deems is currently IN. That’s always a losing game (not to mention wasteful!) since what’s in is constantly shifting. Unless you are staging a house for sale, there is no excuse not to make it a reflection of your taste and likes.

This is why I love your blog. I just spent the weekend with a couple whose London apartment was full of gorgeous objects each with a history and memory. We also visited the V&A which was chockabloc full of ceramics from every era across the globe and I head home, now, with a head full of ideas because these “things” are a visual feast and soothe a busy mind. A good Kondo clear out makes room for better stuff! Love your ideas Kirsty x

Very nice post! As someone else commented, I think I’m somewhere in between minimalist and New maximalist! I love my new white kitchen, but my Roman shade and breakfast nook has a very strong modern floral that is mainly aqua, black, and white! My daughter and son in law like no color other than a warm gray. Their apartment is extremely pleasant though!

Such an inspiring post with gorgeous images!! Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this hot topic!

I appreciate this! While I am probably firmly in the middle between max & min, I’m preparing to move across country, so I want to get rid of it all, lol. I like this positive spin on collecting and curating stuff!

I find myself craving different things at different times of the year. That is probably because I live in Alaska where we go to extremes of dark/cold and light/warmth. I also live in a tiny space. The solution has always been separate storage and curation for the time of year. I find warm colors and rich patterns wonderful in winter… and cool colors and more space needed for summer.

I love maximalism, I live my life by it, but I could never live in any of the spaces in the pictures. Nothing feels natural. It’s like two people worked on each room, one attempting to match everything and the other trying to make everything clash. I don’t know if it’s the designer or the pieces in the room, but something feels so wrong. I know everyone has different tastes but I couldn’t help but make a face at many of these rooms.

Okay, going back through the pictures after posting my comment I think I realized why I personally don’t like this particular style of maximalism. The color schemes are drastically different than the ones I have in my own life and the ones I admire. The design is actually pretty good it’s just the pieces themselves I’m not vibing with. I mainly use pastels, so the vibrant colors weren’t doing it for me.

I was so happy to hear about maximalism a year ago as it summed up how I am. I was feeling the shame like I was “supposed” to downsize my stuff. Only thing I did Marie Condo on was my clothing and items such as cosmetics, toiletries. We truly are mini museums of history and curators of amazing items. I really like to think of that way and needed to hear that. 🙂 I have lots of fabulous items and I love them all, and many things inherited from family members no longer with us.

Maximalism, in almost every form is hideous. It is a cluttered, clashing car crash of junk, usually in garish mismatched and childish colours designed to appeal to those too busy or lazy to take the time and effort it takes to develop taste. It is a cancer in the world of design and it is high time those with taste took a stand against this abomination.

I relished your article from start to finish. I am ALL in, fully immersed. You described everything so perfectly, absolutely everything, right down to the table settings being different every time (& mixed & matched). I am invigorated, excited, inspired by the images you posted as I love color, pattern, texture, art, artifacts, instruments, hardware, fixtures, textiles, inventive use of items…art in EVERYTHING! I guess we are a rare specimen, those of us who get it & thrive in it. “Clutter” encourages creativity. Einstein’s desk was extremely cluttered. Many famous authors & artists in the past have had homes just like these. Maximalism is like a living multidimensional collage. It is most definitely an art form. My home is a mix of museum, library, and art gallery. I have no sense of too much as I love layers and collections. A bare wall looks stark to me. When I see minimalist or beige homes, it’s depressing to me, lacking any personality. I savor vintage and I strive to preserve it for future generations. Vintage items are generally built to last as well, a testament to why they will outlive us all versus today’s modern non serviceable plastic molded items that you can’t even disassemble by use of screws. Vintage items are also usually environmentally superior, as I said…built to last, made of wood or metal or glass versus plastics. Of course there are vintage plastics too, but those items tended to be serviceable. People are very critical of maximalism and seem disgusted, but I am about curation and appreciation and joy in the whimsical and interesting and beautiful. In my view, it’s expressing one’s unique style, instead of being on the constant ride of consumerism of the latest trend.. talk about being environmentally unsound, discarding everything because you tire of it with the next latest trend, not having lasting appreciation for it, always having to have “new” & discarding & replacing. For years now, I see “farm house” everywhere…bogus farm house, not authentic but what manufacturers have churned out. The chronic trendy consumers will discard their generic farm house stuff when the next big thing comes around, just like the fate of shabby chic & Parisian, mauve/aqua/sage green Southwestern, etc., as readily as they discard their wardrobe when something else is in fashion, whether it’s flattering or not. The trendy consumers will have their future design dictated & defined by whatever the current fad is, not by their own style, as they seem to be lacking one. I like some current things as well, but if there’s ever anything currently sold that I might like, I am assured I will eventually find it in a thrift store (like Anthropologie mugs or Nathalie Lete dishes I found over time) because of how easily others tire of things or because they broke one dish & now have an incomplete set. MIs-matched? Yes, thank you! Matching furniture or dishes are stifling to me & lack personality or interest. (My cupboards & dishwasher are always a riot of color & pattern & visually delicious. I have, on numerous occasions, taken photos of my dishwasher with all of the different colorful combinations that are beautiful together.) If there’s a matched set, it better have a whole lot of other curated things to offset the sterility of conformity. I love handmade items as well, as they have so much character compared with mass produced. I see barren homes & it seems to me like it’s just a place to sleep, not to savor & enjoy as your sanctuary. I have a chronic illness & am primarily homebound much of the time, but I bring nature into my home with natural history curations & art. I am NEVER bored in my home, always stimulated in a grand & joyful way, not a negative way. I always have at least 10 ideas & projects I want to do. Friends tell me that my home is happy & cheerful & I know it’s interesting & has humor as well as beauty. Being stuck at home in a pandemic is not a problem for me. I am extremely content in my collage of museum, art, library, whimsy, color, pattern, texture, history, & layers. I do enjoy my many things, but I am not materialistic in the way of needing status or keeping up with the neighbors. I never had an engagement ring because that does not have meaning to me… my husband’s & my mutual love & commitment was the only importance & a ring couldn’t possibly have more meaning that that. Our wedding bands are plain but meaningful in their simplicity. (We both are auto mechanics & our hands & rings took a lot of abuse over the years). All of our cars are old, we never buy new. I have never desired a Coach purse or similar. I can’t tell you the names of most current designers. I would never pay more for a label. Brand names do not necessarily equal quality. I do not strive to appear rich. If I won the lottery, I would not buy a mansion or expensive cars, etc. I do not need the latest. I love artful clothing that I mix & match from thrift stores, but I do not desire to be noticed…I only love the colors, patterns & designs for myself. I am generous with others & am eager to give & do not desire or expect it to be reciprocated. I too appreciate the stories behind vintage items and the people who had them before me and it makes me happy to think of the people who will enjoy them after me. It is very much about the history of everything & preservation for future generations to appreciate art, ingenuity, and quality, especially since so much of that has declined with modern consumerism (from the art of packaging to being built to last in past generations to the book covers & illustrations of vintage books). I want to live in & fully enjoy my home as I like it, rather than living in it for some future prospective buyers. Our home has so much of our personality, I can’t imagine parting with it. I have seen that some people buy homes only to tear them down & build new on the lot anyway. Why should I live now in sparse sterility for it to be someone else’s future dream home? It started out as a generic suburban tract home but it’s my dream home now with lots of character & the future folks can do as they please. I acknowledge that most people prefer minimalism & neutrals and find peace/tranquility in the sparseness of it, and they should have their dream home & savor it, but perhaps they can understand better that maximalism is about appreciation & creativity & curation & not the same as hoarding. I too expect an incredible estate sale when I’m gone and maybe my many layers will inspire the buyers to relish the art of the living collage & preservation. Thank you for your fabulous & expert dissection of the meaning & appreciation in maximalism with your article that is so insightful & adeptly written. I hope more people can understand what you’re saying, the meaning & appreciation & authenticity, rather than just reducing it to a style that they object to. We are kindred, creative, nonconformist, appreciative, big thinking & misunderstood spirits. 🙂

I love this! I love design so I didn’t hate any of these rooms! I am definitely in the maximalist category and love color. I would become so bored with all neutrals. Last year I built a farmhouse, . It may be all white outside but the inside is totally unexpected boasting aquas, teals, royal blue with a coral barn door and coral lamps. Admittedly, I was terrified picking paint etc. The anxiety came with what I knew I “should” pick verses what I felt would make me happy. I worried what others would think since the expectation and the “rules” of farmhouse was the all white walls with all neutral decor accents. But I stepped back and I thought about where I was building which is my grandmother’s property and I live on Robinson Drive. My parents live in my grandparent’s home. In fact , my dad lived there his whole life. They definitely live in a white farmhouse. But guess what? My grandmother used color like turquoise etc. I decided that although Joanna Gaines is a talented designer. She shouldn’t dictate that farmhouses are all white inside.(at least for the most part) My husband had to say to me a few times, “Be bold. Be Lynnette.” I think ultimately he knew if I did the expected he would be having to repaint every room. In the short term. LOL

“I would die of boredom in a neutral, minimalist home” Because, I suspect you don’t understand minimalism. Properly done, it’s anything buy neutral. But for some, neutrality as you put it is the point. I find maximalism aesthetically hideous and mostly superficial. The beauty of materials and space get lost in a compost pile of overly saturated colours and meretricious design. Of course, taste is a personal matter and what constitutes good taste is a very broad church but it does have its limits, I think few would deny that some people’s personal taste is questionable. I think maximalism, in its more extreme forms is over that limit.